“- Interviewee: I don't believe in witches and airy-fairy stuff like that.
- Heather Donahue: Are you a religious man, Sir?
- Interviewee: Yes.
- Heather Donahue: Alrighty...”
Jim King - Interviewee
Heather Donahue - Herself

“- James Leer: It's just... for good luck. Some people carry rabbits' feet...
- Prof. Grady Tripp: ...You carry firearms.”
Tobey Maguire - James Leer
Michael Douglas - Prof. Grady Tripp

“- William Forrester: In some cultures it's good luck to be wearing something inside-out.
- Jamal: And you believe that?
- Jamal Wallace: No, but it's like praying: what do you risk?”
Sir Sean Connery - William Forrester
Rob Brown - Jamal Wallace

“- James: What are they?
- Old Man: Crocodile tongues.
- James: Tongues?
- Old Man: Long, slimy crocodile tongues boiled in the skull of a dead witch for 40 days and 40 nights. And, the gizard of a pig, the fingers of a young monkey, the beak of a parrot and three spoonfuls of sugar, and then, let the moon do the rest.”
Paul Terry - James
Pete Postlethwaite - Old Man

“I knew it in my heart. You can buck the system but you can't buck the dark forces that lie hidden beneath the surface. The ones some people call superstitions.”
Matt Dillon - Bob